Last Crumb, the cookie brand known for its three-day process and inventive flavors, arrives on Lexington Avenue early, and it’s bringing gifts. On Nov. 23, the brand opens a build your own box holiday gifting experience inside its future storefront at 990 Lexington Avenue. Guests choose every cookie, fill the box and leave with the best gift on their list. The experience runs through Dec. 31, giving the Upper East Side its first taste of Last Crumb before the permanent shop opens.
Step through the black drapes and the room goes quiet. Individually wrapped cookies sit under warm light like pieces in a jewelry case. Guests pick a six or 12 cookie box and build it one cookie at a time. Mint Royale goes to the one who runs on peppermint lattes. Bah Crumbug goes to the coworker who swears they hate the holidays. Every box says exactly what the giver thinks of the person opening it.
A Last Crumb box needs no explanation. It shows up ready to impress and gets talked about long after the wrapping paper hits the floor. The lineup leads with the signatures, including The O.G. (Chocolate Chip), The Floor Is Lava (Chocolate Lava), Donkey Kong (Banana Cream Pie), Macadamnia (Salted Caramel Macadamia), Mint Royale (Mint Chip), Tinsel Town (Birth, Netflix and Crunch (Cinnamon Toast Crunch), The Madonna (Peanut Butter) and plus Ghost of Chocolate Past, a cookie created with Paramount Pictures’ Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol. Even Scrooge would make room on his list.
Last Crumb treats every cookie as a standalone dessert. The Head Baker develops each flavor’s recipe entirely from scratch and gives it its own custom compound butter and its own dedicated bake temperature. Zero shared dough. Each cookie takes three days from dough to finished product, and the team makes every component in house at its South Williamsburg kitchen, from caramels and creams to fruit compotes and pastes. Every layer earns its place, and Last Crumb never cuts corners or uses preservatives.
“Luxury isn’t a gold ribbon. It’s knowing someone spent three days on the gift you’re giving,” said Casey Terrell, CEO of Last Crumb. “Last Crumb lets guests build a box that says exactly what they think of the person receiving it. We can’t wait to welcome the neighborhood this holiday season, then come back in the new year with our permanent Upper East Side shop.”
When gifting wraps on Dec. 31, Last Crumb closes the space to finish the permanent shop with custom counters, new lighting and a full back of house buildout. The doors reopen ahead of Valentine’s Day, making the Upper East Side the brand’s second New York City storefront after Williamsburg. Brooklyn is home. Manhattan is next.
The build your own holiday box experience runs Nov. 23 through Dec. 31 at 990 Lexington Avenue from 11 am to 8 pm Sunday through Thursday and 11 am to 10 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Guests can also visit the Williamsburg location at 144 N 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, open 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Wednesday and 11 a.m. to midnight Thursday through Sunday. Order online at https://lastcrumb.com or on Goldbelly at www.goldbelly.com/restaurants/last-crumb.
About Last Crumb
Last Crumb creates indulgent, ingredient-forward cookies crafted with obsessive attention to quality and ingredient selection. Led by an in-house Head Baker who refuses to cut corners, every Last Crumb flavor launches with its own unique recipe, custom compound butter, and dedicated bake temperature. The brand uses no preservatives, ever. Last Crumb delivers cookies that celebrate comfort, nostalgia, and pure indulgence through bold, creative flavors and elite-level craftsmanship.
